Sep 4, 2001 · Feanor was an extrodinary skilled elven craftsman, problem is he was a mighty Elf too, to say the least. When the mighty ones get angry, usually a lot more is wrecked then when the peaceful old hobbit next door gets enraged. Feanor worked so hard on the Silmarrions, only to see them get stolen by the only one who surely did not deserved to have ...

Apr 30, 2003 · Wrong. Just your opinion. He was driven, inspired, full of energy, brilliant , talented and a mover of history. Inspired? How? What intelligent move did he ever make? He was a brilliant craftsman. That's it! At lot of people move history. …

Dec 14, 2022 · @Vairë likes first person, and I tend to copy whoever I'm with so I'm doing that as well. So I'm not really a narrator, every character is narrating.

Feb 3, 2003 · Feanor 's my favorite Elf from a third-person standpoint; he's just such a fascinating character. As far as which one I liked the best, I'd have to say Fingolfin.

Sep 10, 2002 · See, that's my problem. Its kind of hard for me to believe that she was a Maia -- she almost killed Melkor, the most powerful Vala, but for the host of Bakrogs that came to his rescue and drove her away. On the other hand, Tolkien does not write about any other spirits besides the Valar and...

Aug 10, 2002 · Welcome to The Tolkien Forum! Connect with fellow Tolkien enthusiasts and join a community that is nearly two decades old, and still going strong. We look forward to meeting you. Register Forums The Works of J.R.R. Tolkien "The Lord of the Rings"

Nov 15, 2004 · Also, there seems to be a pleasure in hurting from these villians, sadism, if you will. That isn't misguided love. It is simply hate. Exactly. I tink that all Sauron did was derived from hate of everything good.

Mar 8, 2003 · Okay, enough crazyness. Ecthelion was the better fighter, but Glorfindel was the greater Lord. They just about even out, each with a 9 (on a 1-10 scale). Legolas and Fingolfin also recieve 9's, (though they are so much cooler), and Feanor recieves a 10 (he was the greatest Elf that ever lived; and that's a fact). Well, that's my opinion.

Mar 20, 2005 · Guys, guys, there's no reason to get cantankerous at one another. The four of us are obviously having a marvellous time nit picking to death. ;) Alcuin, I agree with the whole of your last post. Likewise, I don't lean to one side more than the other - …

Feb 3, 2009 · There was a certain member here a few years ago by the alias of Cían (and I most certainly would like to put him on my list and even on the Durin VII list!) who I personally believe made Grond, Ancalagon and Harad look like third grade English students (and me look like I was in pre-school). He (or was it a she???) would post significantly less than even you L_o_G but …